Compositing Reel 2012

[Hartigan]

Hey guys here is my latest comp breakdown reel, all comments welcome
cheers
Rob

https://vimeo.com/44855528

[Gentle Fury]

It's very long. There is definitely no reason to spend 22 seconds on one shot. There is also no need to show the same shot over and over. If its really short, you can show it once clean and once comped....or do a wipe then fully comped....but showing it more than once just gets annoying and repetitive.

[kero]

Agreed. There is some nice work on there, but you need to be more brutal with the editing. You could show the same set of work in under 1:30 and it would have much more impact.
I'd also suggest starting with your comp for each shot and then wiping to the original plate - not the other way round. For a lot of them, just wipe to the plate once and move back to the comp - no need to show the plate twice and then repeat the shot afterwards. And because there are many similar shots you probably don't have to break down each one. With a little polish this could be a minute and a half of really good reel.

[Lurival Jones]

Belo trabalho Hartigan!
Parabéns!